Volume 24, Number 1, January 2023
Volume 24, Number 1
DownloadWelcome to the 6th meeting of the INTOSAI Working Group on Environmental Auditing, 10-12 April 2000, Cape Town, South Africa!
Dear colleagues,
In 1998, in Peru and Uruguay the strategy of regionalisation was adopted for the INTOSAI Working Group on Environmental Auditing. The implementation of this strategy began in 1999. At this moment in time, almost all INTOSAI-regions started up a regional working group on environmental auditing. This is a monumental achievement!
Our Working Group meeting in Cape Town, which starts today, marks a very important moment for our Working Group. The number of 39 delegates from 23 participating SAIs to this meeting is more than ever. I would like to welcome all delegates, especially those delegates who attend a meeting of the Working Group for the first time.
It is also a very important moment, because we are firmly 'en route' to the XVIIth INCOSAI meeting, which will be held next year in Seoul, Republic of Korea. This meeting therefore is not only a good opportunity to further encourage the regionalisation process within the INTOSAI regions, but also to look forward to the future, i.e. after Seoul 2001. This meeting is the best opportunity we have to exchange ideas and views on these subjects. As you have seen, the agenda for the meeting is quite extensive. We will talk about a number of products of our Working Group, such as the draft INTOSAI booklet "Guidance on conducting audits of activities with an environmental perspective", the Working Group discussion paper on "Sustainable development" and the draft discussion paper "International Environmental Accords to Audit". But we will also talk about the way we want to present the activities and products of the Working Group at the XVIIth INCOSAI and, very importantly, the organisational shape of the Working Group after 2001.
This edition of Green Lines gives an overview of the final programme of the meeting. As you will see, some very small adjustments have been made. Furthermore, some topics of general intrerest are brought to your attention.
I look forward to our exchange of ideas and discussions in the next two days. I hope we will have a productive meeting together.
Saskia J StuivelingFinal programme Cape Town meeting
|
Day |
Location |
Time* |
Programme |
|
10 April 2000 |
First Floor Pool Deck |
18.00–19.00 |
Welcome cocktail hosted by Auditor General of South Africa, including Group Photograph |
|
11 April 2000 |
Salon la Concorde |
8.30-12.00 |
Working session A
|
|
12.00-12.45 |
Lunch |
||
|
12.45 |
Start boarding the busses for the tour |
||
|
13.00-Evening |
Environmental excursion followed by dinner hosted by the Auditor General of South Africa |
||
|
12 April 2000 |
Salon la Concorde |
9.00-12.30 |
Working session B
|
|
12.30-13.30 |
Lunch |
||
|
Salon la Concorde |
13.30-17.00 |
Working session C
|
|
|
First Floor Lobby & Terrace |
17.00-18.00 |
Farewell cocktail hosted by the Chair of Working Group on Environmental auditing |
* Adjustments to the programme are written in italics
Final list of delegates and SAIs attending the meeting
|
Country |
Delegates for Cape Town meeting |
Position in national Audit Institution |
|
Austria |
Dr. Heinrich Lang |
Rechnungshof of Austria |
|
Brazil |
Mr. Fabio H. Granje E Barros Mrs. Rosangela Fleury |
Tribunal de Contas da União Tribunal de Contas da União |
|
Cameroon |
Prof. Francois-Xavier Owona Ndouguessa |
Director of Training and International Co-operation |
|
Canada |
Mr.Wayne Cluskey |
Principal Environment |
|
Czech Republic |
Mr. Zdenek Smelik Mr. Miroslav Kruchina |
Member of the College of teh SAO Head of Department of Environment and Construction |
|
Egypt |
Mrs. Samia Labib |
General director, Central Auditing Organization |
|
Georgia |
Mr. Zurab Dvali |
Deputy Chairman |
|
Indonesia |
Mr. Sahid |
Court of Audit of Indonesia |
|
Korea |
Mr. Min-Cheol Shin Mr. Jaeboong Lee |
Board of Audit and Inspection Board of Audit and Inspection |
|
European Court of Auditors |
Mr. Francois Colling |
Member of the European Court of Auditors |
|
Netherlands |
Mrs. Saskia J. Stuiveling Mrs. Saskia van der Haagen Mr. Floris Roijackers Mrs. Sylvia van Leeuwen |
President Netherlands Court of Audit, Chair Intosai Working Group Environmental Auditing Assistant to Mrs Stuiveling Staff member Working Group Secretariat Staff member Working Group Secretariat |
|
New Zealand |
Mr. Martin Pinkard |
Senior auditor |
|
Norway |
Mrs. Therese Johnsen Mrs. Carmen Fuentes Arends |
Director General Performance Audit Department Audit advisor |
|
Pakistan |
Mr. Nasrul Ghaznavi |
Auditor Generals Office |
|
Poland |
Mr. Zbigniew Wesolowski Mr. Andrzej Glowacki Mrs. Ewa Borkowska-Domanska |
Vice-President of Supreme Chamber of Control Deputy Director of Organisation Department Supreme Chamber of Control |
|
Romania |
Prof.. Ioan Condor Mrs. Marilena Demian |
Chairman of the Romenian Court of Audit Auditor |
|
Russian Federation |
Mr. Sergey Openshev Mr. Vladimir Bogachev |
Member of the collegium Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation |
|
South Africa |
Mr. Wessel Pretorius Mr. Graham Randall Mr. Pramesh Bhana |
Corporate Executive Manager Executive manager Centre Manager |
|
Saudi Arabia |
Mr Abdul Aziz Abdullah A Hemid Mr. Saad Al-Qutham |
General Auditing Bureau General Auditing Bureau |
|
United Kingdom |
Mr. Joe Cavanagh |
Director Environment and Transport |
|
USA |
Mr. Steven Elstein |
General Accounting Office |
|
Zimbabwe |
Mr. E Harid Mrs. Josephine Mukomba |
Comptroller and Auditor General Deputy Auditor General |
Language at the meeting
In the previous Green Lines it was mentioned that the secretariat of the Chair experienced some communication problems, also because of the use of different languages. Therefore, we would like to ask all delegates to communicate as much as possible in English. English is the official language of the Working Group.
The Chair of the Working Group will be accompanied by three members of her staff: Mrs. Saskia van der Haagen, assistant to Mrs. Stuiveling, Mr. Floris Roijackers and Mrs. Sylvia van Leeuwen, staff members. The staff is responsible for the substantive content of the meeting, and can be contacted for all questions related to the programme of the meeting and (most) other practical matters.
The Office of the Auditor General of South Africa will be represented by a staff of five persons. Mrs. Debbie van der Westhuizen is responsible for all the logistic and practical details of the organisation of the meeting in Cape Town. Mrs. Annatjie Morgan is the assistant to Mrs. Van der Westhuizen and is responsible for registrations. Furthermore, three ladies form the Cape Town office of the South African SAI will be present for assistance: Lisl Skrikei, Odette Fouri and Kim Tait.
The Staff can be reached at the Delegate Assistant Desk and Secretariat Office located at the first floor (Boardroom B), phone 1969 or at mobile number: 082 458 0480.
In the previous Green Lines it was announced that from 17 to 22 March 2000 hundreds of water specialists, politicians, leading experts and top officials from all across the globe would convene in The Hague, The Netherlands, for the Second World Water Forum. Information on the Second World Water Forum can be found at: http://www.worldwaterforum.org/
The meeting resulted in the following "Declaration of The Hague":
|
World Water Forum Ministrial Declaration: Water Security in the 21st Century
In the Ministerial Declaration providing Water Security in the 21st Century is identified as a common goal. This means "that protection and improvement of fresh water, coastal and related ecosystems is ensured; that sustainable development and political stability are promoted, that every person has access to enough safe water at an affordable cost to lead a healthy and productive life and that the vulnarable are protected from risks of water-related hazards". According to the Ministers and Heads of Delegation, to achieve water security seven main challenges have to be adressed: 1) Meeting basic needs 2) Securing the food supply 3) Protecting ecosystems 4) Sharing water resources 5) Managing risks 6) Valuing water 7) Governing water wisely The actions advocated by the Ministers and Heads of Delegation are based on integrated water resources management. This takes account of social, economic and environmental factors and integrates surface water, groundwater and the ecosystems through which they flow. It depends on collaboration and partnerships at all levels, from individual citizens to international organisations, based on a political commitment to, and wider societal awareness of, the need for water security and the sustainable management of water resources. To achieve integrated water resources management, the Ministers and Heads of Delegation observe a need for coherent national and, where appropriate, regional and international policies to overcome fragmentation, and for transparent and accountable institutions at all levels. To this end, Ministers and Heads of Delegation declare to establish targets and strategies, will support the development of indicators of progress at the national and sub-national level, will work together with other stakeholders to develop a stronger water culture through greater awareness and commitment, and to increase the effectiveness of pollution control strategies, will work within multilateral institutions to strengthen water-related policies and programmes that enhance water security, and to assist countries to address the major challenges. |
|
|
The full text of the Ministerial Declaration you can find on www.worldwaterforum.org The Third World Water Forum shall be convened in March, 2003 in Japan. |
Staying informed easily on Multilateral Environmental Accords
The world wide web provides interesting possibilities to stay informed of developments concerning Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEAs). An easy way to stay informed is to subscribe to newsletters that secretariats of MEAs publish.
For example the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) publishes the newsletter Synergies in which updates are given on environmental treaties that are UNEP- and UN-administered (www.unep.ch/conventions). Environment House News is an interesting periodical that contains many articles on issues relating to MEAs. It is published by the International Environment House in Geneva (www.environmenthouse.ch). The International Maritime Organisation (IMO) publishes a newsletter with much information on IMO-administered treaties (www.imo.org). Finally, Down to Earth is the newsletter of the secretariat of the Convention to Combat Desertification. Subscription to free electronic versions of newsletters like this, sent to you by e-mail, could be an easy way to stay informed on a basic level.
Email addresses of representatives, 12 April, 2000
|
Representatives |
E-mail address (for SAIs without email: fax-number) |
SAI of |
|
Mrs. Marlies Alberts |
environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl or m.alberts@rekenkamer.nl |
The Netherlands |
|
Mrs. Liliana Alfaro Ramirez |
dci00@condor.gob.pe |
Peru |
|
Mr Abdul Aziz Abdullah A Hemid |
Fax: 4032057 |
Saudi Arabia |
|
Mr. Saad Al-Qutham |
Fax: 4032057 |
Saudi Arabia |
|
Mrs. Carmen Fuentes Arends |
carmen.arends@riksrevisjonen.no |
Norway |
|
Mr. Marco Argandona |
dci00@condor.gob.pe |
Peru |
|
Mr. Luis Fernando Vargas Benanides |
inforcgr@cgr.go.cr or |
Costa Rica |
|
Mr. Oivind Berg Larsen |
oivind.beng-larsen@riksrevisjonen.no |
Norway |
|
Dr. Helmut Berger |
berger@rechnungshof.gv.at |
Austria |
|
Mr. Pramesh Bhana |
prameshb@agsa.co.za |
South Africa |
|
Mr. Vladimir Bogachev |
mailto:Czylis@gov.ru |
Russian Federation |
|
Mrs. Ewa Borkowska-Domanska |
intosai@nik.gov.pl |
Poland |
|
Mr. Octavio Augusto Airaldi Brizuela |
ast-cgr@sce.cnc.una.py |
Paraguay |
|
Mr.Victor Enrique Caso Lay |
dci00@condor.gob.pe |
Peru |
|
Mr. Joe Cavanagh |
joe.cavanagh@nao.gsi.gov.uk |
United Kingdom |
|
Mr. Wayne Cluskey |
cluskewj@oag-bvg.gc.ca |
Canada |
|
Mr. Francois Coling |
francois.colling@eca.eu.int |
European Court of Auditors |
|
Mr. Ioan Condor |
rei@rcc.pcnet.ro |
Romania |
|
Mrs. Marilena Demian |
reverdy@moon.ro or |
Romania |
|
Mr. Zurab Dvali |
Fax: ## 8832 968271 |
Georgia |
|
Mr. Steven Elstein |
elsteins.rced@gao.gov |
United States of America |
|
Mr. Fabio H. Granje E Barros |
fabiohg@tcu.gov.br |
Brazil |
|
Mrs. Rosangela Fleury |
mailto:Marcialm@tcu.gov.br |
Brazil |
|
Mr. Nasrul Ghaznavi |
dgga@isb.apollo.net.pk |
Pakistan |
|
Mr. Andrzej Glowacki |
intosai@nik.gov.pl |
Poland |
|
Mr. Rodolfo Gonzalez C. |
mrobayo@contraloriagen.gov.co |
Colombia |
|
Mr. Peter Gray |
nao@gtnet.gov.uk |
United Kingdom |
|
Mr. Peter Guerrero |
guerrerop.rced@gao.gov |
United States of America |
|
Mrs. Saskia van der Haagen |
environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl ors.vanderhaagen@rekenkamer.nl |
The Netherlands |
|
Mr. E Harid |
harid@auditgen.gov.zw |
Zimbabwe |
|
Dr. Rafael Hernán Contreras |
mailto:Cdcr@es.com.sv |
El Salvador |
|
Mr. Manzur Hussain |
unknown yet, see Mr. Ghaznavi |
Pakistan |
|
Mrs. Estella Alvarado Izaguirre |
ealvarado@condor.gob.pe |
Peru |
|
Representatives |
E-mail address (for SAIs without email: fax-number) |
SAI of |
|
Mrs. Therese Johnsen |
therese.johnsen@riksrevisjonen.no |
Norway |
|
Mrs. Karin Kuller |
riigikontroll@sao.ee or karin_kuller@sao.ee |
Estonia |
|
Mr. Miroslav Kruchina |
miroslav.kruchina@nku.cz |
Czech Republic |
|
Mrs. Samia Labib |
fax: ## 00202 4017086 |
Egypt |
|
Mrs. Sylvia van Leeuwen |
environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl ors.vanleeuwen@rekenkamer.nl |
The Netherlands |
|
Dr. Heinrich Lang |
lang@rechnungshof.gv.at |
Austria |
|
Mr. Jaeboong Lee |
mailto:jeaboong@bai.go.kr |
Rep. of Korea |
|
Mr. Olav Lüüs |
riigikontroll@sao.ee |
Estonia |
|
Mr. Mauricio Machón |
cdcr@es.com.sv |
El Salvador |
|
Mrs. Marcia Magelhaes |
marcialm@tcu.gov.br |
Brazil |
|
Mr. Juan Carlos Migone Guzman |
dci00@condor.gob.pe |
Peru |
|
Mrs. Josephine Mukomba |
mukomba@auditgen.gov.zw |
Zimbabwe |
|
Mr. Sergey Openshev |
mailto:czylis@gov.ru |
Russian Federation |
|
Mr. Mamdoh Oran |
audit-b@amra.nic.gov.jo |
Jordan |
|
Prof. Francois-Xavier Owona Ndouguessa |
Fax: ## 237 234403 |
Cameroon |
|
Mr. William Peplow |
william.peplow@magnet.mt |
Malta |
|
Mr. Martyn Pinckard |
mailto:Martinm@oag.govt.nz |
New Zealand |
|
Mr. Wessel Pretorius |
mailto:wesselp@agsa.co.sa |
South Africa |
|
Mr. Graham Randall |
grahamr@agsa.co.za |
South Africa |
|
Mrs. Martha Robayo C. |
mrobayo@contraloriagen.gov.co |
Colombia |
|
Mr. Floris Roijackers |
environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl or f.roijackers@rekenkamer.nl |
The Netherlands |
|
Dr. Peter van Roozendaal |
environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl orp.vanroozendaal@rekenkamer.nl |
The Netherlands |
|
Mr. Sahid |
asosai@bpk.go.id |
Indonesia |
|
Mr. Min-Cheol Shin |
shinmc@koreasai.go.kr |
Rep. of Korea |
|
Mr. Zdenek Smelik |
zdenek.smelik@nku.cz |
Czech Republic |
|
Mrs. Saskia J. Stuiveling (chair) |
environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl |
The Netherlands |
|
Mr. Olavi Tammemäe |
riigikontroll@sao.ee |
Estonia |
|
Mr. J. Augustin Torres |
inforcgr@vgr.go.cr |
Costa Rica |
|
Dr. David Turbay Turbay |
mrobayo@contraloriagen.gov.co |
Colombia |
|
Mr. Zbigniew Wesolowski |
intosai@nik.gov.pl |
Poland |
|
Mr. David Wood |
woodd.rced@gao.gov |
United States of America |
|
Mr. M.P.S. Yoedono |
asosai@bpk.go.id |
Indonesia |
|
Mr. Paco Toledo Yallico |
dci00@condor.gob.pe |
Peru |
Homepage-addresses of SAIs attending the meeting
|
Country |
Delegates for Cape Town meeting |
Homepage on internet |
|
Austria |
Dr. Heinrich Lang |
|
|
Brazil |
Mr. Fabio H. Granje E Barros Mrs. Rosangela Fleury |
SAI: www.tcu.gov.br |
|
Cameroon |
Prof. Francois-Xavier Owona Ndouguessa |
|
|
Canada |
Mr.Wayne Cluskey |
|
|
Czech Republic |
Mr. Zdenek Smelik Mr. Miroslav Kruchina |
|
|
Egypt |
Mrs. Samia Labib |
|
|
European Court of Auditors |
Mr. Francois Colling |
|
|
Georgia |
Mr. Zurab Dvali |
|
|
Indonesia |
Mr. Sahid |
|
|
Rep. of Korea |
Mr. Min-Cheol Shin Mr. Jeaboong Lee |
|
|
Netherlands |
Mrs. Saskia J. Stuiveling Mrs. Saskia van der Haagen Mr. Floris Roijackers Mrs. Sylvia van Leeuwen |
|
|
New Zealand |
Mr. Martyn Pinckard |
Www.oag.govt.nz |
|
Norway |
Mrs. Therese Johnsen Mrs. Carmen Fuentes Arends |
|
|
Pakistan |
Mr. Nasrul Ghaznavi |
Address will be sent later |
|
Poland |
Mr. Zbigniew Wesolowski Mr. Andrzej Glowacki Mrs. Ewa Borkowska-Domanska |
|
|
Romania |
Prof. Ioan Condor Mrs. Marilena Demian |
To be open soon, address will be sent later |
|
Russian Federation |
Mr. Sergey Openshev Mr. Vladimir Bogachev |
|
|
South Africa |
Mr. Wessel Pretorius Mr. Graham Randall Mr. Pramesh Bhana |
|
|
Saudi Arabia |
Mr Abdul Aziz Abdullah A Hemid Mr. Saad Al-Qutham |
|
|
United Kingdom |
Mr. Joe Cavanagh |
|
|
USA |
Mr. Steven Elstein |
|
|
Zimbabwe |
Mr. E Harid Mrs. Josephine Mukomba |
Homepage-addresses of Working Groups
|
Intosai Working Group |
|
|
Afrosai |
|
|
Asosai |
|
|
Eurosai |
|
|
Olacefs environmental commission: |
|
|
Spasai |
www.oag.govt.nz |
Please let us know if the list is incorrect or incomplete.
Note: new members: please let us know your e-mail address; we will include it in the next number of the Green Lines.
|
Edited by The Netherlands Court of Audit Corresponding address: Mrs.Saskia van der Haagen PO-box 20015 2500 EA Den Haag The Netherlands Telephone: #31-70-3424194 Fax: #31-70-3424411 E-mail: environmental.auditing@rekenkamer.nl |
Look at the posters in Salon la Concorde at all time!
Results of the Second World Water Forum & Ministerial Conference in The Hague, the Netherlands
Staff of the Office of the Auditor General of South Africa
Practical information: who to contact with questions
Staff Mrs Stuiveling
Dear INTOSAI WGEA Members and other readers,
A year has passed since becoming the Auditor General of SAI Finland and the Chair of the INTOSAI WGEA. This year has been a great opportunity for me to lea…
Dear INTOSAI WGEA Members and other readers,
It is time for us to celebrate the 30th Anniversary of INTOSAI WGEA! Having just welcomed the 82nd SAI as a member, our work is more relevant than ever. Th…
INTOSAI Working Group on Environmental Auditing (WGEA) aims to increase the expertise in environmental auditing and to enhance environmental governance with high-quality contribution and visibility by both members of the Working Group and non–member SAIs. Currently INTOSAI WGEA consists of 83 member countries.
